Candlesview Open charts
Blog › Practice and review

Checklists and setups that actually get used

13 November 2026 · 5 minute read · Practice and review

A short pre-trade checklist per setup, ticked honestly, turns a trading record into something you can question. It shows patterns. It does not prove causes.

Name the setup first

A setup is one repeatable situation you trade, with a name. "Pullback in an uptrend" is a setup. "It looked good" is not.

Naming matters because results only make sense in groups. If every trade is its own special case, there is nothing to compare. Two or three named setups are enough to start with. Each one gets its own checklist, because the things that matter for a breakout are not the things that matter for a pullback.

Write rules that can be answered yes or no

A checklist item has to be answerable in a few seconds, before the trade, with yes or no. "Trend is up" invites argument. "Price is above the 50 average on the daily chart" does not.

An example for the pullback setup:

1. Daily close is above the 50 average. 2. Price has returned to a level it turned at before. 3. The stop is beyond the last swing low. 4. The loss at the stop is no more than 1% of the account. 5. No major scheduled news in the next hour.

Five items. A list of fifteen will not be read under pressure, and a list that is not read is decoration. If an item is always ticked, it is not doing any work and can go.

Record the ticks, including the missing ones

The checklist is not a gate that every trade must pass. The useful part is the record. For each trade, save which items were ticked and which were not.

This only helps if the unticked trades are recorded as honestly as the ticked ones. Tick before entry, not afterwards. After the result is known, memory changes what you think you saw.

In the Candlesview paper terminal you can attach a setup and its checklist to a trade when you place it, so the ticks are saved with the trade and not rebuilt later.

Reading results with and without a rule

After enough trades, split them by one rule at a time. Say there are 40 trades of one setup, measured in R (multiples of the amount risked).

Rule 2 was ticked on 28 of them. Those averaged +0.3R, for a total of 28 x 0.3 = +8.4R. It was not ticked on 12. Those averaged -0.2R, for a total of 12 x -0.2 = -2.4R. All 40 together made 8.4 - 2.4 = +6.0R, an average of 6.0 / 40 = +0.15R per trade.

On the page, the trades that followed rule 2 did better than the ones that did not. That is worth noticing.

Why that is not proof

Three things stand between that table and a conclusion.

The groups are small. Twelve trades averaging -0.2R can be two bad losses and ten ordinary trades. Remove the two and the gap may vanish.

The rules overlap. Trades that miss rule 2 may often miss rule 3 as well, so you cannot say which one made the difference.

And the trades differ in ways the list does not record. Trades taken without a rule ticked are often the ones taken when tired, bored or chasing a move. The missing tick may be a sign of the state you were in, not the cause of the result.

So read the split as a question to follow up, for example "what was going on in those 12 trades?", and not as a finding that rule 2 adds 0.5R.

Keeping it alive

Review on a schedule, perhaps every 20 trades per setup, not after every loss. Change one item at a time and note the date, so later results can be compared with earlier ones.

Expect the list to get shorter. Items that never change a decision go. Items you keep skipping either become stricter or get removed honestly. Do not leave them on the list and ignore them.

A checklist does not make a setup profitable. It makes your own behaviour visible: what you said you would do, what you did, and what happened in each case. That is the part you can change.

To take away

  • Give each setup a name and a short list of yes-or-no rules.
  • Record which rules were ticked before entry, including the trades where some were not.
  • A with-and-without split raises questions. Small groups and overlapping rules mean it proves nothing.

Try it

Paper tradingLearning centre

Keep reading

Practice and review · 4 minExit efficiency: how much of the move did you keep?

Exit efficiency is the share of the best available move that a trade actually kept. Nobody keeps all of it, and one trade says nothing. The pattern over many does.

14 November 2026
Testing ideas · 4 minCompare every backtest with simply holding

A backtest that made 18% sounds good until you learn the market rose 30% over the same months. The comparison with holding is the first check, not the last.

21 November 2026
Testing ideas · 5 minEight matches is not evidence

A scan matched 8 times and price rose after 6 of them. That feels like 75%. Here is why it says almost nothing, and what to compare it with before believing it.

20 November 2026

Education only. Nothing here is financial advice or a recommendation to buy or sell anything; examples are arithmetic, not results. Trading involves a high risk of losing money.