Trading myths you can test yourself
9 things traders repeat to each other. We do not tell you which are true. Each has a button that runs a simple version on the market and timeframe on your chart, and a note on what to look at. The answer changes with the market, the timeframe and the years tested, which is the real lesson.
"The golden cross is a reliable buy signal"
When the 50-candle average crosses above the 200-candle average, the market is said to be starting a long rise.
What to look at: Count the trades: there are very few, so one lucky or unlucky trade decides the result. Compare with simply holding.
"RSI below 30 means buy"
An oversold reading is said to mean a bounce is due.
What to look at: In a strong downtrend RSI can stay under 30 for a long time. Look at the worst fall and the longest run of losses.
"Breakouts are where the money is"
Buying a new high is said to catch the big moves.
What to look at: Most breakouts fail. Look at the share of winners (usually well under half) and whether the few large wins pay for the rest after fees.
Test it: Turtle-style 20-candle breakout Read the exact rules
"Price always returns to the average"
A stretch away from the Bollinger Band middle is said to snap back.
What to look at: It often does, until the one time it does not. Look at the largest single loss against the average win.
Test it: Bollinger mean reversion in a range Read the exact rules
"The trend is your friend"
Trading only with the long-term trend is said to tilt the odds.
What to look at: Run it, then run the stress checks. Does it still beat holding when fees are doubled and a fifth of the trades are missed?
Test it: Trend pullback (EMA 200 + EMA 50 cross) Read the exact rules
"A squeeze always leads to a big move"
Very low volatility is said to come before a strong directional move.
What to look at: Volatility does expand after a squeeze. The direction is the hard part: look at how many releases went the wrong way first.
"Candle patterns predict reversals"
An engulfing candle is said to mark a turn.
What to look at: Compare the average trade with the random-entry check. If random entries with the same exits do about as well, the pattern adds little.
Test it: Engulfing candle with the trend Read the exact rules
"Markets fill the weekend gap"
A market that opens Monday far from Friday is said to come back.
What to look at: There are only about fifty weekends a year. Count the trades before believing any percentage.
"The first pullback in a new trend is the safest entry"
A dip soon after a trend starts is said to be low-risk.
What to look at: Look at the result by weekday and hour in the stress checks, and at how few trades a year it gives.
Test it: First pullback in a strong trend Read the exact rules
Each test is a simplified version of the claim, on one market and one stretch of the past. A result either way is evidence about that test only. Past results do not predict future results, and nothing here is financial advice.